UFO202 is either very quiet or very loud/clipping

Contributor - Level 1
I just got my UFO202 to move a huge number of my 12" singles and LP's to digital format. The problem I am having is with my turntable from the 90's. The USB output from the UFO202 to my computers USB is either extremely high and therefore clipping, or it is very very low.

Any suggestions on how to get around this?